Confessions of a Reformed Viral-Chaser: What Happened When I Stopped Optimizing
Photo: R Ashwani Banjan Murmu, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Let me tell you about the best-performing thing I ever published here. Millions of impressions. Tons of shares. And I couldn't tell you a single person who actually read it.
That's the thing nobody mentions about going viral: it feels like winning a raffle at a party where you don't know anyone. Congratulations, the crowd loved you. Which crowd? Doesn't matter. They're already gone.
This is my confession, and my argument, for why I stopped chasing viral—and why you might want to consider it too.
The Treadmill I Built for Myself
When this site was younger, I did everything the growth gurus tell you to do. I studied posting times like they were stock options. I A/B tested headlines until the words stopped meaning anything. I wrote articles engineered to trigger outrage, curiosity gaps, listicle dopamine—the whole playbook.
And look, it worked. Numbers went up. I'd refresh analytics like a day trader, riding every spike, spiraling on every flat week.
But somewhere in there, I stopped being a writer and became an optimizer. Every piece I published was aimed at a stranger. The work got shallower. The topics got more generic, because generic travels fast. And the worst part? The readers who'd been here since the beginning—the ones who left actual comments, who emailed me about pieces that hit home—could feel the difference. A few of them told me so.
The Math That Broke My Brain
Here's a stat that rearranged my priorities: in any given viral spike, the overwhelming majority of that traffic never returns. Ever. It's a sugar rush with a hard crash.
Meanwhile, the small, loyal audience—the people who'd follow this site to the ends of the earth—were worth more in a year than any single viral hit. They read everything. They share things thoughtfully. They buy things. They stick around when you write something weird and personal that the algorithm would never bless.
Viral reach is rented. Community is owned. I know that sounds like a LinkedIn bumper sticker, but once you internalize it, you can't un-see it.
What I Did Instead
So I made three changes, and I'd recommend all of them to any creator reading this:
1. I started writing to one person. Not a demographic. A person. Someone who's commented before, whose taste I know. Every piece now has a name attached to it in my head. Sounds corny. It works.
2. I killed the content calendar. I used to publish on a rigid schedule because the algorithm supposedly rewards consistency. Now I publish when I have something worth saying. Fewer posts, better posts, zero filler. My output dropped by half and my engagement per piece doubled.
3. I optimized for replies instead of reach. The metric I care about now is simple: did anyone talk to me about this? A piece that sparks forty genuine conversations beats a piece that gets forty thousand drive-by impressions. Every time.
The Freedom Nobody Warns Me About
Here's what surprised me most: the anxiety didn't just shrink. It mostly vanished.
When you're chasing viral, every post is a referendum on your worth. When you're writing for your people, every post is a conversation with friends. One of those is a knife fight. The other is dinner.
I also got funnier and weirder, honestly. Viral content has to be for everyone, which means it can't really be for anyone. Work made for a specific community can take risks, run inside jokes, go deep instead of wide. Some of my favorite pieces I've written ran to a fraction of my old traffic—and generated more meaningful response than anything that ever trended.
For the Creators in My Comments
I know a lot of you reading this make your own stuff—art, music, newsletters, videos, whatever. So let me save you two years of treadmill:
- Find your fifty true ones before you find your fifty thousand. Serve the fifty. They're the foundation; the crowd is weather.
- Make the thing only you would make. The algorithm rewards sameness. Your actual advantage is the stuff nobody else can copy.
- Measure what matters to you, not what's easy to measure. Replies, relationships, and pride in the work. Those don't show up on a dashboard, but they compound.
- Give yourself permission to be boring sometimes. Not every piece needs to be a statement. Consistency of voice beats spikes of brilliance.
Where This Leaves Me
I'm not saying growth is bad. I'm saying growth is a byproduct, not a target. Aim at the work and the people it's for, and the numbers tend to follow—slower, sure, but stickier and saner.
The viral stuff taught me how the machine works. This—writing for the folks who actually know this site by name, who've been here through every era—that's the part I'm keeping.
If you've been here a while: thank you. This one's for you. It always was, honestly. I just needed a couple million strangers to figure that out.