One Month, One Comment Section, Total Chaos: What Happened When You Picked My Project
Photo: Acabashi, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
So I did the thing. I posted a video, opened a poll, and told you — all of you — that for one month, whatever won the vote would be my next project. Full creative surrender. Sight unseen. I said it with a smile on my face and a small knot in my stomach, because I've been on this internet long enough to know exactly what happens when you hand a comment section the keys.
They happen to have happened. Let's get into it.
The Leaderboard of Chaos
The early frontrunner, by a landslide: "make a ballgown out of gas station merchandise." Not with gas station materials, mind you — themed around it. Someone wanted a ballgown inspired by Slim Jims. Over four hundred votes. I want you to sit with that.
Close behind: a jeans-to-jacket refactor, which, fine, that's a real suggestion and I've done it before. Then came "a quilt but it's a map of Ohio," which I'll admit made me laugh out loud in a parking lot. And then the sabotage wing of the operation showed up: "knit a sweater with your feet," "make a hat out of your old keyboard," and my personal favorite, just the word "sweat."
Four hundred and eleven votes for sweat. Democracy is beautiful and terrifying.
Comment #847
But here's why I'm glad I did it, and why I'll probably do it again with guardrails. Buried deep in the thread — comment #847, from an account with no profile picture and eleven followers — was this: "My grandma used to remake her husband's work shirts into aprons after he passed. Nobody does that anymore. I'd watch that."
I read it three times. Then I closed the app and sat with it for a minute, because that comment contained an entire documentary. Memory, grief, utility, love, all folded into one suggestion that got maybe six upvotes. The algorithm of the crowd picked the Slim Jim ballgown. The crowd's quietest member picked something real.
I made the aprons. Three of them, from a stack of my dad's old work shirts that had been sitting in a closet for years. It was the most emotionally loaded thing I've made all year, and I never would have chosen it myself. That's the honest case for handing over the keys sometimes: you don't know what you're missing until somebody who isn't you points at it.
Where the Line Actually Lives
So did the audience pick my project? Sort of. Did they pick my direction? Absolutely not, and I don't think they should. Here's the line as I now draw it:
A community is great at surfacing ideas and terrible at making decisions. A thousand people can tell you what's interesting. Only one person can tell you what's true for your hands, your skills, your reasons for making. The moment I let votes decide the meaning of my work, I stop being a maker and start being a vending machine.
The Slim Jim ballgown, for the record, is not happening. (It is maybe happening as a joke for the newsletter. Don't tell anyone.) The aprons are done, they're in the world, and comment #847, wherever you are — thank you. Genuinely.
Next month I'm picking my own project. But I'll be reading the comments. All of them. Even the ones that just say "sweat."