Five People I Met in a Comments Section (And Why I Stopped Calling It 'Just the Internet')
Photo: Wilfredor, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons
Somebody on Twitter — I refuse to call it X, we're not doing that — once replied to me that comment sections are "where nuance goes to be embalmed." Which is funny, honestly, because that reply was one of the wittier things anyone's said to me, and it happened in a comment section.
That's the thing about the internet's reputation problem: we've all agreed, collectively, that comments are the sewer. The doomscrolling discourse, the ratio, the guy who shows up under every post to explain your own job to you. And sure, that guy exists. I've met him. He has met all of us.
But I've now spent over a decade being a follower — of newsletters, of artists, of small podcasts with eleven listeners — and I'm here to make the unfashionable case that the comment section is one of the last genuinely underrated social spaces in American life. Not the reply-guy cesspool. The other one. The one where people keep showing up.
Here are five people who prove it.
1. The Stranger Who Corrected Me (Kindly)
Early in my blogging days, I wrote a post about zine culture in the '90s and got a detail wrong about a Portland distro. A reader named Marisol left a comment that started, "Hey, small correction, and thanks for the nostalgia trip —"
That dash did a lot of work. She corrected me, complimented me, and left the door open, all in three sentences. I emailed her. She ran a community print shop in Oregon. Two years later she helped me put together my first physical chapbook, and to this day she's the person I send drafts to when I can't tell if a piece is done.
The lesson: the best commenters aren't the ones who agree with you. They're the ones who show up with expertise and manners, a combination rarer than it should be.
2. The Guy Who Commented Every Single Week for Two Years
Every creator knows this person. Mine was a fella named Dwayne out of Columbus, Ohio, who commented on my newsletter every single week — thoughtful, specific comments, the kind that prove you read the thing and not just the subject line.
After about two years, I finally asked him why. His answer wrecked me a little: he'd retired early due to a health issue, missed having colleagues, and had decided that being a good reader was his way of having coworkers again.
We now talk on the phone monthly. He's the only person I know who has strong opinions about both font licensing and Ohio State football. I did not find a friend. A friend found me, in a comment box, and just kept showing up until I had the sense to notice.
3. The Collaborator I Never Would Have Chosen
Selection bias is real. Your friends tend to look like you, think like you, live in your zip code's cultural cousins. A comment section doesn't care about any of that.
A reader named Priya left a long comment disagreeing with a piece I wrote about hustle culture — respectfully, thoroughly, with citations. I was annoyed for about an hour and then grateful for about a year. We ended up co-writing a series together, and her whole framework came from a world I'd never worked in. The piece was better because she'd walked in through the comments with a different set of tools.
If you only ever befriend people who already agree with you, your work calcifies. The comment section, at its best, is an accidental diversity machine.
4. The Mentor Who Was Never My Mentor
I don't think Ruth ever considered herself my mentor, which is probably why it worked. She was a retired art director in Chicago who'd leave these dense, generous comments on my process posts — never praise, always observation. "The composition's fighting the message in paragraph four," that kind of thing.
She never once asked for anything. I eventually figured out she'd spent forty years doing exactly what I was fumbling toward, and that her comments were basically a free master's degree delivered in 200-word installments. She passed away last spring. I still reread her comment history like it's a textbook, because it is one.
5. The One Who Just Made Me Laugh
Not every connection needs a narrative arc. There's a commenter — handles change, I won't dox them — who has replied to my posts for years with jokes that make me snort-laugh in coffee shops. We've never spoken outside the thread. I don't know their real name. I would notice their absence within one post.
Community isn't only collaboration and mentorship. Sometimes it's a stranger who reliably makes Tuesday funnier, and that's not a lesser form of connection. That's the whole ballgame, honestly.
The Case for Showing Up
Here's my actual opinion, stated plainly: we've let the worst ten percent of commenting behavior define the entire practice, and in doing so we've abandoned one of the few low-stakes places where sustained attention still happens.
Liking a post takes half a second. Sharing it takes two. But writing a real comment — reading something, sitting with it, responding to what was actually said — takes the one resource nobody fake: time. A good comment section is a room full of people who chose to spend time on the same thing. That used to be called a community. It still is.
So if you're a lurker: come on in, the water's warmer than you think. And if you're a creator: answer your comments. Somewhere in that little box is your next collaborator, your Dwayne, your Ruth.
Embalmed nuance, my foot. Some of the best conversations of my life started in a reply thread.