The Shoulders of a Stranger: In Defense of Everything I Never Finished
Photo: unfinished craft projects on shelf quilt squares, via i.etsystatic.com
On the top shelf of my studio closet, wedged between a dead Cricut and a box of holiday ribbon, lives what I've come to call my shelf of almosts.
There's a nine-patch quilt square in blues that don't match anything else I've ever made. There's issue one of a zine about neighborhood murals — written, laid out, never stapled, never sent. And there's the big one: a mural I painted on a freestanding panel back when I thought I'd do more large-scale work. It stops at the shoulders. The face was never started.
For years I treated these things like evidence. Proof of a bad habit, a pattern of starting and abandoning. Then one afternoon, looking for a drop cloth, I pulled them all down at once and something shifted. These aren't failures. They're the most accurate record I have of who I was at the moment I made them.
What Finished Work Hides
Here's the thing about a finished piece: by the time it's done, it's lying to you.
Not on purpose. But a completed quilt square in a finished quilt tells you a tidy story — here is a decision, executed. The nine-patch on my shelf tells a messier, truer one. It tells me I was learning color theory from a library book. It tells me I ran out of the good navy and improvised. It tells me I stopped exactly when the project stopped being about the quilt and started being about whatever was happening in my life that spring.
Finished work is a summary. Unfinished work is a diary entry.
I've started thinking of unfinished projects the way archivists think of working documents — the drafts, the marginalia, the crossed-out lines. A museum shows you the painting. An archive shows you what the painter was wrestling with. My closet shelf is a small, dusty archive of my own wrestling.
The Mural That Stopped at the Shoulders
The mural panel deserves its own paragraph because it took me the longest to make peace with.
I had this idea — a portrait of my grandmother, based on a photo taken outside a house in Texas that I've never actually seen in person. I got the shoulders done over two weekends. The fabric of her dress took forever and I loved every minute of it. Then I hit the face, and the face required a version of attention I didn't have in me that season, and the panel went against the wall, and the wall became a closet.
I've thought about finishing it. Honestly, I probably never will. But here's what I know: those shoulders are the only piece of large-scale painting I've ever committed to, and they taught me more about brush control, about scale, about my own stamina, than any finished piece I've made since. The project did its work on me before it was done. Maybe that's the actual function of a project — not the object, but the change it makes in the maker.
A Taxonomy of Almosts
Once I started paying attention, I realized every creative person I know has a version of this shelf. A friend in Portland has a novel that stops at page 112 — she can tell you exactly what happens in the rest of it, which is somehow better than having written it. A guy in my ceramics class has eleven matching mugs with no handles. Eleven! He talks about them like a man describing his children.
I've noticed the almosts tend to fall into a few types:
- The Skill Gap. You stopped because the project demanded something you didn't have yet. These hurt the most and teach the most.
- The Lost Why. You stopped because the reason you started stopped being true. These are the ones you shouldn't finish.
- The Season Changed. Life interrupted, and by the time it didn't, you'd become someone else. These are time capsules.
Different types, different fates. The skill gap almosts can be revisited. The lost whys should be released without guilt. The season-changed ones? Those you keep exactly as they are, because they're not really projects anymore. They're photographs.
The Invitation
So here's what I'm asking, and I mean it literally: show me your shelf of almosts.
Post it in the comments, send it in a DM, bring it to a meetup if we ever do another one. The half-knit sweater. The unsent zine. The mural that stops at the shoulders. I want to build something with it — a community gallery of unfinished work, no explanations required, no promises to finish anything.
Because a portfolio tells people what you can do. Your shelf of almosts tells people what you care about. And in my experience, that second list is the one worth sharing.